![]() But in this story, it mainly simplifies Seymour- talking about him from a third perspective and making him seem broken and small, rather than a time hardened man with complex emotions. This stuck out to me mainly because I see it morphed in BANANAFISH, usually commenting on the protagonist. ”Mother,” said the girl, “you talk about him as though he were a raving maniac-“ This is a small quote that made me think about the main theme- war, and the returning soldiers who suffer. However rereading the conversation not only gave me a better picture of Seymour, one of the protagonists, but also was sad to see how people are so dismissive of their loved one’s struggles if they cannot relate. I’d heard lots of people mention A Perfect Day for Bananafish, and how it featured a war-ragged soldier crumbling into his inner child, and a little girl. When the story opened in a conversation between a mother and daughter, I was confused. :banana: Themes I Saw in A Perfect Day for Bananafish :banana: ![]() THE FOLLOWING SECTIONS WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS FOR “BANANA FISH” & “A PERFECT DAY FOR BANANAFISH” It contains subtle themes of innocence and later, blatant violence, so if you want to read it, check those warnings out first. It speaks of greed and tragedy, as well as the disconnection war inserts into veterans. This story is about a soldier returning from war, telling a little girl about a fantastical fish the bananafish. Salinger, an author famously known for his book, Catcher in the Rye. However, if you plan on watching the show, make yourself aware of the triggers.Ī Perfect Day For Bananafish is a short story written by J. While the show itself has 18+ themes and violence, my review/comparison will not mention any of these, so I’m not including a warning(s). It’s animated by Mappa, and contains 24 episodes. Here’s a quick summary of how I see these medias to catch you up There will be spoilers later on however.īANANA FISH ( バナナフィッシュ) is an anime that follows the story of Ash Lynx and his companion, Eiji Okumura as they try and discover the secrets behind the mysterious words “banana fish” all the while learning friendship, loss, and more. :fish: Haven’t seen BANANAFISH? Haven’t read A Perfect Day for Bananafish? Never fear! :fish: I had a lot of fun doing this-which surprised me since this is essentially English homework but with an anime instead of Shakespeare :skull: Good practice before school’s back I guess. This will be comparing the BANANAFISH *anime* not the manga.įull of online strangers who will destroy Salinger, as the former was heavily influenced by the latter.Īlso, keep in mind this is just my opinion! I know a lot of this could be interpreted differently, but here’s how I see it. So, I decided to compromise: here is a comparison of symbols, motifs, and themes between the BANANAFISH story written and illustrated by Akimi Yoshida in contrast to the “A Perfect Day for Bananafish” short story written by J. But a quick read through the guidelines made me realize it might not be appreciated if I go into the nitty-gritty details of such a dark and explicit anime. Now, I was all for writing a regular opinion review on Banana Fish. Quotes from the story will be necessary to support your argument.Hi! So…I did two polls on what I should write about next a general poll and a tiebreaker poll between “Noragami” and “banana fish.” I decided since “banana fish” was winning on the prior poll, and “Noragami” was winning on the second, I’ll just do them in that order. The thesis will be your own argument supported by the text of the story. Do not use secondary sources (research) in writing this paper. What techniques does Salinger use to make his characters’ conversations sound realistic? Write your paper as though your audience has read the story and that you, as critic, will help them better understand how to interpret it. Some of the possible topics you might consider include the following: Why did Seymour commit suicide? What is the significance of the Bananafish story Seymour tells Sibyl? Why does Seymour become angry at the woman in the elevator? Is Seymour a pedophile? Was this Salinger’s intention in portraying the characters the way he did? How does Salinger use symbols and allusions to enhance the story? Most of the story consists of dialogue. In other words, don′t tell what happened in the story, but rather, tell what the events, characters, elements of irony or symbolism in the story mean. Please note that a critical interpretation is not a plot synopsis it is an analysis that examines various literary elements in the writing to demonstrate the author’s purpose. Write a 1000-word critical interpretation paper about some aspect of the story “A Perfect Day For Bananafish,” by J. Paper, Order, or Assignment Requirements
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |